NNSquad - Network Neutrality Squad

NNSquad Home Page

NNSquad Mailing List Information


[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[ NNSquad ] More on Yahoo takedown demand for "Law Enforcement Compliance Guide"

One additional note on this.

Without a doubt, firms like Yahoo have a legal obligation to
appropriately handle law enforcement requests for information and to
formalize their procedures for dealing with such requests, the latter
specifically to avoid "ad hoc" responses.

The problem in this case is specifically the manner in which these
procedures are being treated as "trade secrets" that -- it's
implied -- would if revealed somehow enable criminal or other illicit
activities that would not otherwise have occurred.

I saw nothing in that document that shouldn't reasonably be public
information, or that represented a risk (other than possible
embarrassment to Yahoo) of any kind.  In fact, the doc represented the
most concise and understandable summary of Yahoo data retention
policies that I've ever seen.

The only aspect where an argument of "proprietary data" might perhaps
be tenable would be in relation to the specific price list for
the various services rendered to law enforcement.

This isn't to say that Yahoo doesn't have a right to keep internal
documents private -- rather that the same information should be made
available to the public at large in an equally useful form.

NNSquad Moderator