NNSquad - Network Neutrality Squad

NNSquad Home Page

NNSquad Mailing List Information


[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[ NNSquad ] Black Magic, Big Lies, and the Perverting of the Internet

           Black Magic, Big Lies, and the Perverting of the Internet


Author Arthur C. Clarke has been famously quoted as saying, "Any
sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

His assertion may be arguably correct, but he neglected to make an
important related stipulation.  Was he referring to good magic or bad
magic?  Did he mean the wondrous powers of Glinda or the dark arts of
the Wicked Witch of the West?

Does it matter?  Isn't technology fundamentally just a set of tools,
mechanisms that take on the ethics (or lack of ethics) of those who
wield them?

One need only look at the way Internet-related issues are being
perverted for greed and political advantage, at the manner in which
Big Lies are dispensed like candy, to see the evil side of the
equation at work.

Even persons who feel that they are soundly grounded in science, the
folks (yes, like me, too) who smile knowingly at the foolishness of
evolution deniers and global warming doubters, who jeer at nutcase
sheriffs and Tea Party toadies -- yes, we're no different in this
respect -- we too can be fooled.

The toxic cauldron of "gotcha" and Big Lie politics, the rise of
illogical conspiracy theories and designated enemies, wars without
end, so-called "friends" we've never really known -- all these and
more have seeped into our collective consciousness, have gradually
undermined our rationality, our thinking, and have likely made most of
us perhaps more than a little bit crazy.

It's as if we now reside within a recurring "Groundhog Day" version of
"The Emperor's New Clothes" -- with fabrications promoted as reality,
and dissembling touted as truth.

In the Internet space, the examples -- many of which I've discussed
extensively in the past -- are all around us, dripping with the putrid
smells of greed, and the lust for power and political control.

Much vitriol is directed at Google these days -- perhaps to be
expected with such a large target, comprised (as are all firms) of
imperfect human beings.

Yet many of the accusations and their promoters are without logic, are
senseless upon the application of even a modicum of serious thought.

Google is accused of what amounts to vast privacy conspiracies, even
though no evidence of such is present, and even given that engaging in
such behavior -- with competitors essentially just a click away --
would likely be suicidal.  Millions of words are angrily written about
Google's legal, though officially unsanctioned, collection of
fragmentary, unencrypted Wi-Fi data from public airwaves, of exactly
the same sort that any of us could easily gather with any modern
laptop or cell phone in a simple drive around practically any
neighborhood in the industrialized world.  Whole websites are devoted
to this "wardriving" hobby, and entire industries have been built upon
such technologies, yet the Big Lie is that Google has done something
awful in this vein.

ICANN, castigated by their own outgoing CEO as being rife with
directly relevant conflicts of interest, continues to pursue its
extortionist domain name expansion "gold rush" scheme, to suck
billions of dollars from the global community toward the enrichment of
anointed sycophants, their hands outstretched to pick the pockets of
the world during already painful economic times.  ICANN's Big Lie in
this instance is that the Internet needs all these new gTLDs, that
somehow the average Joe and Jill will benefit, while in reality the
result will be more confusion, more spam, and more crime for all but
the chosen few who will sit at the top of the increasingly corrupt
Domain Name System pyramid.

The handful of dominant U.S. ISPs fight against Net Neutrality,
against even the merest hint of regulations, while piling on arbitrary
bandwidth caps, data throttling, and anticompetitive streaming
services carefully positioned to take maximal advantage of these giant
ISPs' massive control over most persons' Internet access.  These firms
claim that this is all to the consumers' advantage.  This is yet
another of the Big Lies, indeed.

Our leaders proclaim that "other countries" are the evil censors, the
Internet blockers, the enemies of freedom.  And yet it is the USA
itself that has perverted the rickety obsolescence of the DNS into a
weapon for site shutdowns and global censorship without due process,
that supplants free speech and liberty with the greed of entertainment
industry behemoths, and is now using legitimate cybersecurity concerns
as an excuse to decimate privacy laws while claiming they're doing
exactly the opposite.  These are all facets of a Big Lie we've
collectively heard innumerable times down through the centuries --
that this is all for our good, that anyone who complains is an idiot,
unpatriotic, or both -- and that we should all just shut up and be
docile, cooperative sheep to be sheared.

I've worn out many a keyboard writing of such things in the past.
I've made my voice hoarse in discussions.

I have no desire to tilt at windmills.  I do not underestimate the
forces arrayed to not only protect the status quo, but to push the
dark side ever deeper into our wallets, our lives, our very thoughts.

But if we continue in our complacency, in our willingness to be
manipulated by Big Lies and Big Greed, we will not only have failed to
fight the enemy, to at least try to make some degree of fairness and
rationality an underpinning of our technologies and technological
world, but we will have allowed ourselves to be consumed -- one lie at
a time, one bite after another -- by the beasts of our own creation.

Lauren Weinstein (lauren@vortex.com): http://www.vortex.com/lauren 
Co-Founder: People For Internet Responsibility: http://www.pfir.org 
 - Data Wisdom Explorers League: http://www.dwel.org
 - Network Neutrality Squad: http://www.nnsquad.org 
 - Global Coalition for Transparent Internet Performance: http://www.gctip.org
 - PRIVACY Forum: http://www.vortex.com 
Member: ACM Committee on Computers and Public Policy
Lauren's Blog: http://lauren.vortex.com
Google+: http://vortex.com/g+lauren / Twitter: http://vortex.com/t-lauren 
Tel: +1 (818) 225-2800 / Skype: vortex.com
nnsquad mailing list